Contacts
A Cautionary Tale about Certain Claimed Tax Savings Arrangements Disguised as Wellness Programs
Promoters have long pitched some variation of the following wellness program to employers:
- Employees pay pre-tax contributions to participate in a self-insured group health plan;
- During the course of the plan year, the plan returns most or all of the employee contributions to the employees for the completion of wellness-related activities[1]; and
- The reimbursements are tax free to the participants.
This proposal obviously sounds amazing to prospective employers due to the potential payroll tax savings to the employer and the payroll and income tax savings to employees. Many promoters will even provide some sort of memorandum from the promoter’s legal counsel and/or other written articles supporting the arrangement’s compliance with applicable laws, such as the Internal Revenue Code (IRC).
As the old saying goes, “If it sounds too good to be true, it usually is.”
Buyer Beware
At least three of these types of arrangements have been either rejected outright or limited by the IRS for impermissible tax avoidance.
- The Double Dip
This arrangement is the oldest of the three and generally works as described above. Participants typically receive large reimbursements greatly exceeding any actual out-of-pocket medical expense and/or for completing pretty nominal wellness-related activities. These may include watching a webinar, attending a presentation providing general health information, or attending general health counseling sessions. It may also include participating in more robust wellness activities such as biometric screening.
The IRS has explicitly stated on several occasions that programs whose primary purpose is to refund pre-tax contributions as tax free reimbursements do not qualify for an income tax exclusion for the employee under IRC Sections 105 or 106 when the reimbursements are disproportionately larger than any actual out-of-pocket medical expense (please see Revenue Ruling 2002-3). Despite this clear position, the Double Dip continues to pop up. The U.S. Department of Justice recently convicted the promoters of a Double Dip known as the Classic 105. - The Sleight of Hand
Under the Sleight of Hand arrangement, employees pay a small contribution toward the self-insured group health plan on an after-tax basis. The arrangement may or may not also involve the employees paying significantly larger pre-tax contributions toward coverage. Similar to the Double Dip, participants typically receive large reimbursements greatly exceeding any actual out-of-pocket medical expense and/or for completing wellness-related activities.
The Sleight of Hand is an attempt to move the tax exclusion away from IRC Sections 105 and 106 to IRC Section 104(a)(3) and avoid the IRS’ unfavorable Double Dip guidance on disproportionately large reimbursements. Under IRC Section 104(a)(3), benefits are not taxable to the recipient if the health insurance coverage (or an arrangement that operates like health insurance) is not paid for on a tax free basis.
In IRS Chief Counsel Memorandum 201719025 (released May 12, 2017), the IRS indicated that IRC Section 104(a)(3) does not apply to these arrangements, because the plan cannot qualify as health insurance (or an arrangement that operates like health insurance). This is because there is no actual insurance risk for the participants, all or nearly all of whom are virtually guaranteed to receive benefits far in excess of their after-tax contributions. In addition, the IRS believes this demonstrates a significant portion of the coverage is really being provided on a tax free basis. As a result, the excess of the benefits received over the amount of any after-tax contribution should be treated as taxable income to the employee. - The Flex Credit Switch
This arrangement is similar to the Double Dip or Sleight of Hand, but with a twist. Under the Flex Credit Switch, some or all of the benefits received from the self-insured group health plan are provided as flex credits that can be used to purchase other benefits on a pre-tax basis through the client’s IRC Section 125 cafeteria plan instead of being provided as direct reimbursements.
If the flex credits are used to purchase non-taxable benefits under the cafeteria plan, the flex credits are excluded from the employee’s taxable income. A “non-taxable benefit” is a benefit that can both be paid for on a pre-tax basis and provide tax free benefits to participants. In other words, the Flex Credit Switch works when the flex credits are used for non-taxable benefits.
This makes sense, because the entire exercise amounts to the employee deferring otherwise taxable income to make pre-tax cafeteria plan elections. But…there’s a catch.
Under many Flex Credit Switch arrangements, the benefits that can be purchased with the flex credits are actually taxable benefits. This means the benefits cannot both be paid for on a pre-tax basis and provide tax free benefits. When this is the case, the flex credits are included in the employee’s taxable income (please see IRS Chief Counsel Memorandum 201719025, Situation #2).
Examples of problematic taxable benefits include:
- Most accident and disability benefit products;
- Whole and variable life insurance products;
- Supplemental term life insurance products in excess of $50,000;[1]
- Most fixed indemnity products;[2] and
- Gym memberships.[3]
ERISA Note
We believe permitting employees to pay pre-tax for many fixed indemnity products will also cause them to be considered ERISA plans sponsored by the employer if this wasn’t already the case.
Our Recommendation
We strongly recommend against relying on an opinion letter, memorandum, or articles provided by a promoter selling the claimed tax saving arrangement. We strongly recommend reviewing any claimed tax savings arrangement with your own legal counsel and/or tax advisor before signing up and offering the program to your employees.
[1] The difference, if any, tends to be used to compensate the promoter unless the promoter is paid through other means.
[2] The IRC and related rules only permit the first $50,000 of coverage to be paid for on a tax free basis.
[3] Most indemnity products can provide benefits in excess of unreimbursed medical expenses and are considered at least partially taxable benefits.
[4] We addressed the tax consequences for employer-provided gym memberships in an earlier article.
You May Also Be Interested In
- Event
01.27.2021
Webinar | The New Norm: Maintaining Productivity While Working From Home
- Event
02.04.2021
Webcast | Continued Road to the Vaccine: Clinical and Compliance Considerations for Employers
- Event
02.18.2021
Webcast | HIPAA Privacy and Security Training
- Event
03.16.2021
Webinar | Pay Equity Disputes and Risks
- Event
03.18.2021
Webcast | How to Survive a U.S. Department of Labor Audit
- Event
04.15.2021
Webcast | Qualifying Life Events and Permitted Election Changes
- Event
05.20.2021
Webcast | Wellness Programs
- Event
06.17.2021
Webcast | Mid-Year Compliance Review
- Event
07.15.2021
Webcast | FMLA and Employee Benefits
- Event
08.19.2021
Webcast | Medical Expense Spending Accounts (Health FSA, HRA, HSA)
- Event
09.16.2021
Webcast | COBRA
- Event
10.21.2021
Webcast | Domestic Partner and Non-Tax Dependent Coverage
- Event
11.18.2021
Webcast | ACA Reporting Requirements
- Event
12.16.2021
Webcast | Year-End Compliance Review and Forecast
- Blog
01.25.2021
Summary of Benefits Provisions in the 2021 Consolidated Appropriations Act – Part 2
- Blog
01.22.2021
Annual CMS Medicare Part D Disclosure Due for Calendar-Year Plans
- Event
01.21.2021
Webcast | State Individual Mandate Reporting Requirements
- Blog
01.21.2021
A Bitter Pill to Swallow
- Event
01.20.2021
Webinar | New Developments in the Classification of Workers
- Event
01.13.2021
Webinar | Leave of Absence and Return to Work Issues in the Era of COVID-19
- Blog
12.29.2020
A Coronavirus Update for Employers
- Blog
12.29.2020
A Summary of Benefits Provisions in the 2021 Consolidated Appropriations Act
- Event
12.17.2020
Webinar | Year End Checklist 2020 and Future Forecast 2021
- Blog
12.04.2020
Additional Health Reimbursement Arrangements Allowed Under Final Rules
- Blog
11.20.2020
Federal Agencies Issue Final Rules Addressing Transparency in Coverage
- Event
11.19.2020
Webinar | ACA Reporting Requirements 2020
- Event
11.12.2020
Webcast | 2020 Election Results: The Impact to Benefit Plans
- Blog
10.30.2020
A Summary of 2021 Health and Welfare Plan Limits and Other Annual Adjustments
- Blog
10.22.2020
Final 2020 IRS Forms 1094/1095 Published
- Event
10.15.2020
Webinar | Health Savings Accounts 2020
- Blog
10.14.2020
INSIGHTS Newsletter
- Blog
10.09.2020
Michigan Revises No-Fault Auto Insurance
- Blog
10.09.2020
Affordable Care Act Reporting Relief Extended for 2020
- Event
10.08.2020
Webcast | A Tale of Two Breaches
- Blog
09.24.2020
DOL Issues New FFCRA Leave Guidance
- Event
09.17.2020
Webinar | FMLA and Employee Benefits 2020
- Blog
09.14.2020
Transportation Fringe Benefits Update
- Blog
08.31.2020
Massachusetts Family Medical Leave Update: Renewal of Fully Insured and Self-Funded Private Plan Exemptions, Upcoming Dates, Plan Options and Benefit Coordination
- Blog
08.26.2020
The Empire State Strikes Back
- Event
08.20.2020
Webinar | Compliance Considerations When Self-Insuring 2020
- Blog
07.29.2020
2021 Employer Affordability Safe Harbor
- Event
07.22.2020
WEBINAR | Next Chapter: Massachusetts Family Leave Act 2021
- Blog
07.22.2020
The Rise of State Individual Mandates - July 2020
- Blog
07.22.2020
Massachusetts Paid Family Medical Leave Update (July 2020)
- Blog
07.22.2020
Massachusetts Creditable Coverage – Employer Update (2020)
- Event
07.16.2020
Webinar | Annual Required Notices 2020
- Blog
07.01.2020
IRS Addresses Direct Primary Care and Health Care Sharing Ministries
- Blog
06.30.2020
Proposed ESG Regulation
- Event
06.18.2020
Webinar | Mid-Year Compliance Review 2020
- Blog
06.16.2020
What’s Old is New Again – Annual PCORI Fee is Due July 31st
- Blog
06.16.2020
COVID-19 Plan Administration Relief: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
- Event
05.28.2020
Webcast | COVID-19 Update: Navigating the Coronavirus, Vaccines, Testing and Wellbeing
- Blog
05.28.2020
DOL Finalizes Rule Expanding Use of Electronic Delivery for Plan Documents
- Blog
05.27.2020
A Tale of Two IRS Notices
- Blog
05.27.2020
2021 Plan Limits and Final Coupon Guidance Released
- Event
05.21.2020
Webinar | COBRA 2020
- Event
05.19.2020
Webinar | Legal and Compliance Return to the Workplace: Considerations for Employers
- Blog
05.11.2020
IRS and DOL Extend Filing Deadlines Due to COVID-19
- Blog
04.20.2020
IRS Extends Deadlines Due to COVID-19
- Event
04.16.2020
Webcast | COVID-19: Managing the Impact- Weekly Update 4.16.20
- Event
04.16.2020
Webinar | ERISA Basics 2020
- Blog
04.10.2020
CARES Act Signed Into Law
- Event
04.09.2020
Webcast | COVID-19: Managing the Impact- Weekly Update 4.9.20
- Event
04.02.2020
Webcast | Update on COVID-19: Navigating the Coronavirus and Managing the Impact
- Blog
03.30.2020
CARES Act Provisions Expand Retirement Plan Access for Individuals Impacted by COVID-19
- Blog
03.27.2020
FFCRA Employee Rights Poster Notification Poster Available
- Blog
03.26.2020
DOL Issues New Guidance on FFCRA and Required FFCRA Posters
- Event
03.24.2020
Webinar | Navigating the Coronavirus and Managing the Impact
- Blog
03.23.2020
The Rise of State Individual Mandates - March 2020
- Event
03.19.2020
Webinar | HIPAA Privacy and Security Training 2020
- Blog
03.10.2020
Federal Agencies Issue Proposed Rules Addressing Transparency in Coverage
- Event
02.20.2020
Webinar | Qualifying Life Events & Permitted Election Changes 2020
- Blog
02.13.2020
The Rise of State Individual Mandates
- Blog
02.10.2020
Annual CMS Medicare Part D Disclosure Due for Calendar-Year Plans
- Event
01.23.2020
Seminar | Employment Law Landscape 2020
- Blog
01.22.2020
The Affordable Care Act’s Employer Mandate: Part 4
- Event
01.16.2020
Webinar | Wellness Programs 2020
- Blog
12.26.2019
Repeal, Repeat, Remand – Ho Ho Hum?
- Event
12.19.2019
Webinar | Year End Checklist and Future Forecast
- Blog
12.09.2019
Employer HIRD Form Due on December 15, 2019
- Blog
12.04.2019
Affordable Care Act Reporting Relief Extended for 2019
- Event
11.21.2019
Webinar | ACA Reporting Requirements
- Blog
11.20.2019
IRS Releases Draft 2019 Instructions for Forms 1094/1095
- Blog
11.08.2019
IRS Releases 2020 Limits for FSAs and Other Benefits
- Blog
10.28.2019
The Affordable Care Act’s Employer Mandate: Part 3
- Blog
10.28.2019
Medical Loss Ratio Rebates
- Blog
10.28.2019
California Mandates a Notice Requirement for Flexible Spending Accounts
- Event
10.17.2019
Webinar | Health Savings Accounts
- Blog
10.09.2019
2019 Massachusetts HIRD Form Filing Deadline Approaches
- Blog
10.04.2019
Insurance Carriers Approved for Mass Paid Family Medical Leave Act
- Blog
09.30.2019
New Health Reimbursement Arrangements Allowed Under Final Rules
- Event
09.19.2019
Webinar | New HRA Options
- Blog
09.19.2019
2020 Employer Affordability Safe Harbor
- Blog
09.18.2019
The Affordable Care Act’s Employer Mandate: Part 2
- Blog
09.17.2019
Medicare Part D Notice Reminder
- Event
08.15.2019
Webinar | Association Health Plans
- Blog
08.12.2019
And in this Corner…the Fight to Expand Association Health Plans Continues
- Blog
07.31.2019
New Guidance on Mass FMLA Payroll Contributions and Wage Withholdings
- Blog
07.22.2019
IRS Expands Definition of Preventive Care for Qualified High Deductible Health Plans
- Event
07.18.2019
Webinar | Annual Required Notices 2019
- Blog
07.10.2019
Tax Consequences of Gym Membership Reimbursement
- Blog
07.09.2019
Agencies Release 2020 Adjusted Limits
- Blog
07.08.2019
The Affordable Care Act’s Employer Mandate: Part 1
- Blog
07.01.2019
President Signs Executive Order to Improve Healthcare Price and Quality Transparency
- Event
06.20.2019
Webinar | Mid-Year Compliance Review
- Blog
06.18.2019
Mass Paid Family Medical Leave Update
- Blog
05.28.2019
Potential FMLA Violations
- Blog
05.24.2019
Annual PCORI Fee is due
- Blog
05.23.2019
The Status of Qualified Transportation Fringe Benefits
- Event
05.16.2019
Webinar | Wellness Programs
- Blog
05.03.2019
Massachusetts Online Exemption Application Now Available for Employers Seeking a Private Plan Option to State Paid Family Medical Leave Program.
- Blog
04.30.2019
Massachusetts Employer Alert
- Blog
04.26.2019
Massachusetts Releases New Guidance and Employee Notice Template For Massachusetts Paid Family and Medical Leave (PFML)
- Event
04.18.2019
Webinar | HIPAA Privacy & Security Training
- Blog
04.11.2019
Leave Laws Continue to Multiply
- Blog
04.10.2019
Massachusetts Creditable Coverage
- Blog
04.02.2019
Association Health Plans (AHPs) – Update
- Blog
03.25.2019
U.S. Department of Labor Releases Proposed Overtime Rule
- Event
03.21.2019
Webinar | Federal Continuation Coverage
- Blog
03.19.2019
Deadline Approaching: Paid Family and Medical Leave Act
- Blog
03.06.2019
Reminder: Annual CMS Medicare Part D Disclosure
- Blog
03.05.2019
Mistaken HSA Contributions
- Blog
03.04.2019
Frequently Misunderstood Health Savings Account Issues
- Event
02.21.2019
Webinar | FMLA & Employee Benefits
- Event
02.13.2019
Seminar | How to Survive a DOL Audit
- Blog
02.05.2019
Government Considering Modifications to HIPAA Privacy and Security Rules
- Blog
02.04.2019
Automatic Enrollment Given a Boost
- Event
01.29.2019
Employment Law Landscape 2019
- Event
01.17.2019
Webinar: ACA Reporting Requirements
- Blog
12.31.2018
Slowly Filling in the Blanks
- Blog
12.27.2018
Women’s Contraceptive Coverage under the Affordable Care Act (ACA) – Update
- Blog
12.20.2018
Making a List and Checking It Twice
- Blog
12.18.2018
Texas Federal Court Rules ACA Unconstitutional
- Event
12.14.2018
Webinar | Q4 2018 Health Care Reform Update
- Blog
12.03.2018
An End to Pharmacy Gag Clauses
- Blog
12.03.2018
Employment Law Update: Minimum Wage Keeps Climbing
- Blog
11.29.2018
2018 Form 1094/1095 Reporting
- Blog
11.21.2018
Do the HIPAA Privacy and Security Rules Apply to My Organization? Part Two
- Event
11.20.2018
Webinar | Back to Basics: Consumer-Based Plans 101
- Blog
11.16.2018
Better Late Than Never
- Blog
11.02.2018
Compliance Update: HRAs Poised For a Facelift
- Blog
10.22.2018
FMLA Update - Organ Donation
- Blog
10.18.2018
Do the HIPAA Privacy and Security Rules Apply to My Organization?
- Blog
09.14.2018
Navigating the Wellness Program Rules for 2019
- Event
01.23.2018
Employment Law Landscape 2018
- Blog
10.06.2017
Interim Rules on Contraceptive Exemptions