Understanding Construction Contracts is Critical to Your Success and Bottom Line
Construction contracts are the blueprints to the relationship between the owner and the contracting parties. Contracts provide guidance on how the relationships will work, and the rights and responsibilities of the parties. Understanding what each contract says, and understanding how the contract impacts your company is critical to a project – and to your bottom line.
The Minnesota appellate courts regularly provide contractors with guidance on how to write their contracts, and how to enforce the contract terms. Sometimes the Courts provide contractors with a harsh reminders that all entities in the construction industry must pay attention to and follow all contractual requirements in their agreements. Contractors should be aware of – and heed – these reminders.
For example, in Contractors Edge, Inc. v. City of Mankato, the Minnesota Court of Appeals heard a case involving a construction agreement for a road extension project. The agreement was between the City and Contractors Edge (“Contractor”). A payment dispute arose over the location where the Contractor was required to stock pile and store excavated materials. The agreement specified that a stock pile must be one-half mile away from the project. The Contractor soon realized that the driving distance from the project site to the designated stock pile location was more than a half mile, thereby increasing the Contractor’s hauling costs. The Contractor requested a Change Order to cover the increased hauling costs. The City rejected the request, arguing that the straight line distance between the project and the stock pile location was actually less than one-half mile. The agreement was ambiguous in that it did not specify whether the distance referred to “driving” or “straight line” distance.
The Contractor then submitted a written claim to the City to increase its contract sum. The parties’ agreement required the Contractor to submit written notice of any claim within a prescribed time period, and to provide “supporting data” for the claim. The agreement further stated that the “responsibility to substantiate a Claim shall rest with the party making the Claim.” The City rejected the Contractor’s claim, stating that the Contractor failed to provide the required detailed evidence to support the Claim.
The Contractor then filed a lawsuit to recover the increased hauling costs. The City moved for summary judgment, and the district court granted the motion finding that the Contractor’s “notice of claim” did not provide the “supporting data” as required by the parties’ agreement. The Minnesota Court of Appeals agreed with the district court’s decision, holding that the Contractor’s failure to provide the data with its written notice meant that it did not fulfill the agreement’s requirements to present a valid Claim. As such, the Contractor’s notice of claim was ineffective.
Again, this case is a harsh reminder that contractors must follow all requirements within their agreements to ensure that they get paid. The risk of having an otherwise valid claim rejected for a failure to comply should not be a risk that a contractor be willing to accept.
Instead, avoid risk by thoroughly reading, understanding, and comply with all contract terms.
Another recent example of reminders from the Minnesota Court of Appeals is found in Storms, Inc. v. Mathy Construction Company. In this case, the Court reminded contractors that they must follow the terms of the contract. More importantly, the Court warned – failure to comply with all terms will prevent you from getting paid.
In this case, Mathy Construction Company solicited bids from subcontractors in response to a MNDOT solicitation for bids for a road-repair project. Mathy secured the MNDOT contract. Storms and Mathy then entered into a subcontract.
The road-repair project was completed in August 2011, and in May 2012, in response to a request by Mathy seeking payment, MNDOT issued a change order reducing the amount owed to Mathy. The reason for issuing the Change Order was that the planned quantity amounts for the project exceeded the actual amounts necessary to complete the project. Storms sought payment from Mathy, which refused to pay because of the Change Order and subsequent reduction in payment from MNDOT. Storms brought suit against Mathy, arguing that it was entitled to payment of the full subcontract amount because the Change Order came outside the time period prescribed by MNDOT specification 1402 (allowing MNDOT to change the details of the project at any time during the progress of the work).
This opinion by the court of appeals reverses that district court opinion denying Storms damages for breach of the subcontract. The court of appeals determined that the language of the subcontract clearly indicated that “any changes made to the project must be made during the progress of the work because the [subcontract] language indicates that when the change is made, there is still work left to be completed.” The court concluded that MNDOT’s Change Order, issued nine months after completion of the project, was not valid under the subcontract agreement. Storms was therefore entitled to damages for breach of the subcontract.
Overall, this opinion warns contractors that: (1) the Court will uphold the terms of your contract agreements; and (2) in order to get paid, contractors should comply with all contract terms. These harsh and continual judicial reminders should motivate every contractor to carefully read and review every contract before they sign it, and to modify the terms as needed to ensure they are acceptable. The reminders should also encourage contractors to seek help interpreting and renegotiating any contract provisions which they are unsure about, or which they feel are vague, burdensome or otherwise objectionable.
Attachments
Download Construction Contracts WhitepaperRelated Offerings
Business InsuranceBusiness Insurance Services & ProductsContract Surety BondsRisk ManagementSafety & Loss PreventionRelated Industries
ConstructionYou May Also Be Interested In
- Event
02.09.2021
Webinar | Back to Basics: Insurance Program Options
- Blog
12.16.2020
Insurance Insights: Digital Health & Emerging MedTech
- Blog
12.04.2020
Winter Weather Safety
- Blog
11.16.2020
Q3/2020 Business Insurance Marketplace
- Event
11.05.2020
Webinar | Auto Liability Strategies When Premiums Soar
- Blog
11.04.2020
Beyond the Pandemic: What your broker should be talking with you about right now
- Blog
10.19.2020
Client Advisory: Increasing Cyber Risks in the Transportation Industry
- Blog
10.16.2020
Client Advisory: Dealing with Increasing Cyber Risks in the Biotech Industry
- Blog
10.14.2020
INSIGHTS Newsletter
- Blog
10.14.2020
Client Advisory: Dealing with Increasing Cyber Risks in Manufacturing
- Blog
10.12.2020
Client Advisory: Dealing with Increasing Cyber Risks in the Health Care Industry
- Blog
10.09.2020
Client Advisory: Dealing with Increasing Cyber Risks in the Construction Industry
- Event
10.08.2020
Webcast | A Tale of Two Breaches
- Blog
10.07.2020
Cybersecurity: Managing Risk in the COVID-19 Era
- Blog
10.05.2020
Why HR is a Key Stakeholder in Cyber Risk Management
- Blog
10.02.2020
Network Security & Privacy Considerations When Organization Shift from WFH to Office Environment
- Blog
09.30.2020
Elements of Cyber Insurance Coverage
- Blog
09.28.2020
Cyber Security and Privacy Concerns: COVID-19
- Blog
09.16.2020
Business Interruption Insurance
- Blog
09.04.2020
Insurance Insights: Real Estate & Hospitality
- Blog
09.02.2020
Insurance Insights: Construction
- Blog
08.31.2020
Insurance Insights: Manufacturing
- Blog
08.28.2020
Insurance Insights: Healthcare
- Event
08.27.2020
Webcast | MMA Q2 2020 Business Insurance Marketplace Update
- Blog
08.26.2020
Insurance Insights: Transportation
- Blog
08.24.2020
Q2/2020 Business Insurance Marketplace
- News
08.06.2020
Charlie Filisko's Article Featured in Properties Magazine
- Event
07.21.2020
Webcast | Senior Care - The New Normal
- Event
06.25.2020
Webcast | Navigating the Cyber Liability as Organizations Return to the Workplace
- Event
06.25.2020
Webinar | Paycheck Protection Program- Q & A Town Hall
- Event
06.18.2020
Webcast | Navigating the D&O Market Through Unprecedented Times
- Event
06.04.2020
Webcast | Navigating Challenging Business Insurance Market Shifts
- Blog
05.18.2020
Q1/2020 Business Insurance Marketplace
- Event
04.30.2020
Webcast | COVID-19: Managing the Impact- Weekly Update 4.30.20
- Blog
04.23.2020
Workers’ Compensation Insurance
- Event
04.06.2020
WEBCAST | Cares Act Overview
- Event
03.26.2020
WEBCAST | COVID-19: Navigating Insurance Implications
- Event
03.24.2020
Webinar | Navigating the Coronavirus and Managing the Impact
- Blog
03.24.2020
MMA COVID-19 Coverage 2020
- Blog
01.15.2020
Business Insurance Marketplace Outlook 2020
- Blog
10.14.2019
Tornado Preparation and Recovery Tips for Ohio Businesses
- Blog
10.09.2019
FDA to Begin Food Defense Plan Inspections on Food Facilities in 2020
- Blog
08.02.2019
Podcast | Choosing Your Broker
- Blog
03.28.2019
Five Trends in the Business Aviation Industry
- Blog
02.25.2019
Top Challenges Facing the Banking and Financial Services Industry
- Blog
02.19.2019
How Technology is Impacting the Wholesale Distribution Industry
- Blog
02.08.2019
Businesses Required to Obtain a Spotted Lanternfly Permit
- Blog
01.16.2019
How Technology is Reshaping the Agriculture Industry
- Blog
01.11.2019
Is Ocean Wave Power the Next Big Thing in Renewable Energy?
- Blog
01.08.2019
Five Technologies Impacting Safety and Productivity in the Construction Industry
- Blog
01.03.2019
Four New Advances that are Revolutionizing the Hospitality Industry
- Blog
12.19.2018
Does Your Company Know What To Do After a Cyber-Attack?
- Blog
12.17.2018
Brain Injuries in the Workplace
- Blog
12.14.2018
New Algorithms to Spot Fake Pictures for Insurance Claim Verification
- Blog
12.10.2018
Digital Transformation Unlocks New Opportunities for Financial Services Industry
- Event
10.25.2018
Framework of a Cyber Breach
- Event
10.18.2018
Workers Compensation Red Flags
- Blog
10.17.2018
What's Keeping CEOs Awake These Nights?
- Blog
07.24.2018
Mid-Year Economic, Insurance and Risk Management Marketplace Update
- Blog
07.05.2018
Construction Industry Employee Engagement
- Blog
06.28.2018
Subcontractors without Workers’ Compensation Coverage May Cost You
- Blog
05.11.2018
Drones: The New Highway in the Sky
- Blog
05.10.2018
Identity Protection: The Right Voluntary Employee Benefit
- Blog
05.09.2018
Flood: Understanding the Risk, Navigating Insurance Options
- Blog
05.08.2018
GDPR is Coming. Are You Ready?
- Blog
05.08.2018
OSHA Compliance Alert
- Blog
05.07.2018
Consider the Fair Labor Standard Act for Internships
- Blog
04.30.2018
Plan Sponsor Quarterly Calendar
- Blog
04.25.2018
Hours of Service Rules for Commercial Drivers
- Blog
04.24.2018
Severe Weather: Why it Matters
- Blog
04.17.2018
Preparing for a Product Recall
- Blog
04.17.2018
Understanding Your Investment Policy Statement
- Blog
04.05.2018
Safety Resources - Excavation Safety Stand Down
- Blog
04.04.2018
Electronic Logging Devices - A Hacker's New Window?
- Blog
04.03.2018
Aviation CGL Coverage and Contracts
- Blog
03.21.2018
Recap of MMA Seminar: Employment Law 2018
- Blog
03.13.2018
Understanding Your Aviation Policy: There's More to Consider Than Price
- Blog
01.31.2018
Texting While Driving
- Blog
10.06.2017
The 4 Myths of IT Data Security
- Blog
09.25.2017
Catastrophic Disasters
- Blog
09.25.2017
Got Hail?
- Blog
09.15.2017
Cyber Breach - Equifax
- Blog
09.05.2017
Employee Retention
- Blog
02.01.2017
A Gap In Coverage
- Blog
10.17.2016
Drones expand business' horizons - and their liability