Author: Debra L. Weiss, Employment Partner at Meagher & Geer
Whistleblowing – the commonly-understood act of exposing activity that is considered to be illegal – first became codified in the United States during the Civil War era with the enactment of the False Claims Act to address the problem of profiteers overcharging the government for supplies. But it was not until passage of the Minnesota Whistleblower Act just 30 years ago that whistleblowing became a major tenet of Minnesota employment law.
Whistleblowing Becomes Minnesota Law
Following a ground-breaking case where the Minnesota Supreme Court held that an at-will employee could pursue a suit against her former employer who terminated her for refusing to fill a customer’s gas tank with leaded gas when the car was clearly meant to be fueled with unleaded gas, the legislature took steps to officially enact the Minnesota Whistleblower Act (the “MWA”) with the primary purpose of prohibiting an employer from retaliating against an employee for reporting a violation of the law in good faith.
While the statute established that employers could not retaliate against an employee who reported a violation of law, it did not, however, define several key terms, such as the meaning of “good faith” or what is meant by “report,” thereby creating ambiguities ripe for the Minnesota courts to interpret. For years, the courts strongly cautioned against construing the MWA too broadly, and many cases hinged on what would not constitute a “report.” Through several landmark whistleblower cases, Minnesota courts concluded that an employee could not establish a legally-actionable whistleblower claim under any of the following circumstances:
- If reporting illegalities was a part of the employee’s general job duties
- If the alleged illegality was already known and addressed by the employer
- If the activity centered on breaches of contract or other common law violations
- Or if the conduct was believed to be illegal, but did not actually violate the law.
For decades, Minnesota courts construed the meaning of “good faith” and “report” narrowly. For example, even if the statement itself identified an illegality, the courts would not allow an actionable whistleblower claim to proceed unless there was evidence that the employee intentionally made the statement to expose an illegality. Stated otherwise, the employee had to have made the statement for the clear purpose of blowing the whistle for the benefit of the public as a whole. The courts were also cautious to conclude that a whistleblower was acting in good faith if reported for their own personal benefit. Instead, the MWA only granted protection to the employee if he blew the whistle for the public good. This effectively prevented employees from making an eleventh-hour report to save their jobs from expected termination.
The 2013 Amendments to the MWA
The Legislature passed amendments to the MWA in 2013, however, which changed the understanding of several of these key terms that had been previously undefined by the statute. A “report,” for example, has now been defined as any communication by an employee about an actual, suspected, or planned violation of a statute, regulation, or common law, whether committed by an employer or third party. “Good faith,” as another example, now refers to any conduct disclosing an illegality, so long as the employee does not make the disclosure knowing that it is false or in reckless disregard of the truth. Unfortunately, that definition is not a bastion of clarity.
On its face alone, the amendments appear to significantly expand the scope of the MWA. First, the amendments eliminate any perceived formality that came with reporting a violation –– an employee can now make a report by simply writing an email, sending a text, or even making a passing comment. Second, the amendments do not limit employee protection to reporting of an employer’s past violations, but instead now cover even future circumstances where an employee believes that their employer was going to break to law, even if the violation has not yet occurred. Third, the amendments make clear that a report can be for a violation of any law, including a common law violation, such as breaching a contract. Finally, the amendments do not include a public-good component in the good faith analysis, leaving some practitioners to question whether this requirement was still necessary.
Then, in 2017, the Supreme Court clarified further, holding that the earlier court-created requirement that an employee must purposely blow the whistle to expose an illegality was no longer the law. Instead, the new meaning of “good faith” merely requires that the report not be made knowingly false or with reckless disregard for the truth. In short, the courts have now effectively chosen to focus on the report’s content, not the employee’s motive or job duties.
What to Do Next?
In light of the amendments and the recent Supreme Court case, the MWA appears to offer substantially broader protections to employees than it ever had in the past. While employers will still be able to argue that the employee was terminated for a legitimate business reason and not because of his or her report or out of spite, it will be increasingly more difficult for employers to get these kinds of cases dismissed as a matter of law. In other words, more of these cases will survive summary dismissal and make their way to a jury. Now more than ever is it critical to review and reconsider your organization’s policies and training, particularly with regard to retaliation. To better protect your business, policies should be crafted that provide employees with a clear and secure reporting system that offers multiple reporting channels. Fostering a culture that allows employees to comfortably voice concerns without the fear of retaliation is vital in minimizing whistleblower liability.
Reinforced training, particularly at all levels of management, is also crucial to ensure that supervisors and managers understand what is required of them as agents of the company, if and when a report is made. Indeed, reports must be treated seriously and investigated, even if it is the tenth report from the same “cry wolf” employee. Organizations would further be wise to properly document the steps that are taken to investigate and address the concerns to demonstrate a transparent and thorough process. Indeed, each report of illegality should be adequately researched to determine merit and whether corrective action could or should be taken. It is also important to provide the complaining employee with appropriate feedback so he or she knows that the concern is being addressed and taken seriously.
Though whistleblowing is an old and well-understood idea, whistleblower law in Minnesota continues to evolve. Proactive management that prioritizes prevention and investigation while shunning retaliation is essential to safeguard your organization. It is an investment worth making. For questions regarding training and advising, email Debra Weiss at dweiss@meagher.com.
Join MMA at the Employment Law Landscape 2019 Event for this annual look at local, regional and federal updates in employemnet law and compliance.
You May Also Be Interested In
- Event
04.14.2021
Webinar | Virtual Care Solutions – Should They Be Part of Your Strategy?
- Event
04.28.2021
Webinar | Employer Advanced Primary Care Solutions
- Event
04.13.2021
Webinar | Understanding How Rx Spend Impacts Your Health Plan
- Blog
04.09.2021
Can Telemedicine Make Health Care Benefits Healthier?
- Blog
04.07.2021
Reality #4: The Expectation of Flexibility
- Blog
03.31.2021
Reality #3: Employee Well-being and Inclusion
- Blog
03.31.2021
WellConnected Resources
- Blog
03.24.2021
Reality #2: HR Takes on a Digitally Transformed Role
- Blog
03.01.2021
Benefits News and Views
- Event
02.09.2021
Webinar | 1+2=5? Understanding Your Benefits Cafeteria Plan
- Blog
02.03.2021
Employee Benefits: Choices are Important
- Blog
02.03.2021
Employee Benefits Must Remain in Focus Year 'Round
- Event
01.27.2021
Webinar | The New Norm: Maintaining Productivity While Working From Home
- Blog
01.21.2021
The 5 New Realities of 2021
- Event
01.20.2021
Webinar | New Developments in the Classification of Workers
- Event
01.13.2021
Webinar | Leave of Absence and Return to Work Issues in the Era of COVID-19
- Event
12.17.2020
Webinar | Year End Checklist 2020 and Future Forecast 2021
- Event
11.19.2020
Webinar | ACA Reporting Requirements 2020
- Event
11.12.2020
Webcast | 2020 Election Results: The Impact to Benefit Plans
- Blog
11.12.2020
Live Well Work Well Newsletters
- Event
10.21.2020
Webinar | Telemedicine: Permanent Solution or Temporary Fix
- Event
10.15.2020
Webinar | Health Savings Accounts 2020
- Blog
10.14.2020
INSIGHTS Newsletter
- Event
10.08.2020
Lunch & Learn: Take Charge Health
- Blog
09.24.2020
DOL Issues New FFCRA Leave Guidance
- Event
09.17.2020
Webinar | FMLA and Employee Benefits 2020
- Event
09.15.2020
Webcast | Benefit Administration: State of the Market
- Blog
08.21.2020
Open Enrollment Going Virtual
- Event
08.20.2020
Webinar | Compliance Considerations When Self-Insuring 2020
- Event
07.22.2020
WEBINAR | Next Chapter: Massachusetts Family Leave Act 2021
- Event
07.21.2020
Webcast | Senior Care - The New Normal
- Event
07.16.2020
Webinar | Annual Required Notices 2020
- Event
06.25.2020
Webinar | Paycheck Protection Program- Q & A Town Hall
- Event
06.17.2020
Webinar | Financial Wellbeing: Essential to the Health of Your Employees
- Blog
06.17.2020
National Safety Month: Check Your Safety Lens with a safety perception survey
- Blog
06.16.2020
Connecting with Your Five Employee Demographics
- Event
05.21.2020
Webinar | COBRA 2020
- Event
05.19.2020
Webinar | Legal and Compliance Return to the Workplace: Considerations for Employers
- Event
04.30.2020
Webcast | COVID-19: Managing the Impact- Weekly Update 4.30.20
- Blog
04.28.2020
Employee Mental Health: More Vulnerable Than Ever During the COVID-19 Crisis
- Blog
04.20.2020
Diversity and Inclusion and the Battle for Talent
- Event
04.16.2020
Webcast | COVID-19: Managing the Impact- Weekly Update 4.16.20
- Event
04.09.2020
Webcast | COVID-19: Managing the Impact- Weekly Update 4.9.20
- Event
04.02.2020
Webcast | Update on COVID-19: Navigating the Coronavirus and Managing the Impact
- Event
03.30.2020
WEBCAST | Employee Benefits & 401K Compliance During The Coronavirus Outbreak
- Event
03.24.2020
Webinar | Navigating the Coronavirus and Managing the Impact
- Event
03.12.2020
Webinar | The Power of Food
- Blog
02.06.2020
AD&D: What Employers and Employees Need to Know
- Event
01.23.2020
Seminar | Employment Law Landscape 2020
- Blog
01.16.2020
Employee Health & Benefits 2020 and Beyond
- Event
12.19.2019
Webinar | Year End Checklist and Future Forecast
- Blog
12.09.2019
Employee Benefits and Perks – Life Science Industry Raises The Bar
- Blog
12.05.2019
Financial Wellness
- Blog
12.03.2019
Building the Foundation for a Successful Implementation
- Event
11.21.2019
Webinar | ACA Reporting Requirements
- Blog
11.05.2019
Before the Turn of the Decade: Important Reminders Regarding Employee Benefits
- Event
10.17.2019
Webinar | Health Savings Accounts
- Blog
10.07.2019
4 Ways to Improve Open Enrollment
- Event
09.19.2019
Webinar | New HRA Options
- Event
09.12.2019
Webinar | New Developments with HRAs and 2020
- Blog
09.10.2019
5 Employee Wellness Initiatives That Work
- Event
08.15.2019
Webinar | Association Health Plans
- Blog
08.02.2019
Podcast | Choosing Your Broker
- Blog
08.01.2019
Wearable Health Care Technology: Fashion Fad or the Future?
- Event
07.18.2019
Webinar | Annual Required Notices 2019
- News
06.21.2019
MMA Midwest Named Second Largest Dayton-Area Employee Benefits Company
- Event
06.20.2019
Webinar | Mid-Year Compliance Review
- Blog
06.20.2019
A New Era of Employee-Centric Work Perks
- Event
05.29.2019
Seminar | Pharmacy - Everyone's talking about it, but what can I do?
- Event
05.16.2019
Webinar | Wellness Programs
- Blog
04.26.2019
Massachusetts Releases New Guidance and Employee Notice Template For Massachusetts Paid Family and Medical Leave (PFML)
- Event
04.25.2019
Webinar | Total Worker Health
- Event
04.18.2019
Webinar | HIPAA Privacy & Security Training
- Blog
04.11.2019
Approaching Healthcare Benefits Strategically
- Blog
04.11.2019
April is National Wellness Month
- Event
03.21.2019
Webinar | Federal Continuation Coverage
- Blog
03.15.2019
Five Ways Employee Benefits Are Advantageous for Smaller Businesses
- Event
02.21.2019
Webinar | FMLA & Employee Benefits
- Event
01.29.2019
Employment Law Landscape 2019
- Event
01.17.2019
Webinar: ACA Reporting Requirements
- Blog
01.10.2019
2019: What to Expect in Employee Health & Benefits
- Event
12.20.2018
Webinar | 2018 Year in Review & Future Benefits Forecast
- Blog
12.20.2018
Making a List and Checking It Twice
- Event
12.14.2018
Webinar | Q4 2018 Health Care Reform Update
- Blog
12.03.2018
Employment Law Update: Minimum Wage Keeps Climbing
- Blog
11.29.2018
IRS Increase Health FSA Contribution Limit for 2019 & Adjusts Other Benefit Limits
- News
11.29.2018
Engaging Your Employees Requires Your Own Engagement
- Event
11.20.2018
Webinar | Back to Basics: Consumer-Based Plans 101
- Blog
11.08.2018
Four Steps Employers Can Take to Help Alleviate the Opioid Crisis
- Blog
11.02.2018
Build a Positive Workplace Culture That Promotes Honest Communication
- Blog
11.02.2018
Compliance Update: HRAs Poised For a Facelift
- Blog
10.25.2018
The Impact of Stress in the Workplace
- Event
10.18.2018
Webinar | Annual Required Notices
- Event
10.12.2018
Webinar | Q3 2018 Health Care Reform Update
- Blog
10.09.2018
IRS Releases Final 2018 ACA Reporting Forms and Instructions
- Blog
10.05.2018
What are the Government's Plans to Solve the Opioid Problem?
- Event
09.18.2018
The Opioid Epidemic: A Public Health Crisis
- Blog
09.17.2018
Is Marijuana the Answer to the Opioid Addiction Problem?
- Blog
09.12.2018
Compliance Update: Medical Loss Ratio Rebates Under the Affordable Care Act
- Blog
09.11.2018
2018 Stop-Loss Survey
- Event
09.06.2018
Webinar | Association Health Plans
- Blog
09.06.2018
Rule #1 For Effective Open Enrollment: Start Early
- Blog
08.21.2018
Tobacco: Still Affecting Businesses’ Financial Health
- Blog
08.17.2018
Open Enrollment: Ways to Control Costs
- Event
08.16.2018
Webinar | Surviving a DOL Audit
- Blog
08.07.2018
Open Enrollment: The Benefits of Smarter Communications
- Blog
08.06.2018
The Opioid Crisis: Using Alternative Approaches to Manage Pain
- Blog
07.25.2018
Is An EAP Worth The Investment?
- Blog
06.29.2018
The DOL's New Association Health Plan Rules and What They Actually Mean
- Event
06.21.2018
Webinar | 2018 Mid-Year Compliance Update
- Blog
05.30.2018
The Opioid Crisis: A Serious Societal and Business Issue
- Blog
12.27.2017
Employee Benefits in 2018
- Blog
10.13.2017
Telemedicine and HSAs
- Blog
10.06.2017
Data Breach Risks During Annual Enrollment
- Blog
09.26.2017
Annual Enrollment
- Event
03.14.2017
The Future of Health Care & Employee Benefits