Skip to Main Content

November 16, 2026

How policy interpretation supported a $500,000 claims outcome

A construction loss involving a historic structure shows how claims advocacy can influence complex coverage discussions.

Summary

  • A construction loss affected a historic building shell under a separate policy
  • Marsh Agency reviewed the policy and helped advocate for the client’s claim.
  • The matter was resolved for the $500,000 loss after further review.

The challenge

Our client was developing and building a new structure. Part of the project involved incorporating a historic building shell, which was covered under a separate policy from the rest of the project. During construction and excavation, cracks developed in the historic building shell. The structure was later deemed unstable and had to be demolished. The damages totaled more than $500,000. After completing an inspection, the carrier declined coverage.

The solution

Marsh Agency engaged our Claims Practice to advocate for the client. We first reviewed the policy and the details surrounding the loss and determined that the loss resulted from shifting earth. The adjuster, however, maintained that the cracks developed because of the building’s own weight and poor design. After several conversations, we stood by our position that the policy could be read to support the client’s claim. To continue negotiations, we engaged our claims management team to review the incident further.

The result

After additional discussion and policy review, the carrier assigned a new senior adjuster to the incident and ultimately revisited its position. The matter was resolved for the $500,000 loss. Because of our policy knowledge and attention to detail, Marsh Agency helps clients navigate complex coverage disputes. 

Total financial impact: $500,000

Coverage decisions are made by the insurer and are subject to the terms and conditions of the applicable policy.
 

$500k financial impact