There are forces trying to court your top talent away from your organization. Whether it’s the street, the valley, or their own entrepreneurial zeal, your best and brightest are hearing the call of many suitors. It could be startups, publicly traded companies, or PE-owned firms that come bearing gifts of equity or a possible exit event. If you can’t offer those kinds of incentives, how can you compete for top talent? Just because you can’t offer an IPO or a stake in the family business or nonprofit doesn’t mean you’re limited to choosing between high pay and high executive turnover.
Incentives can be a powerful way to keep top talent engaged. Executives want to be rewarded, and they want that reward to reflect the value they bring to the business. That reward may come in the form of stock or non-equity compensation, but more than anything, they want to share in the company’s success.
Treat your top talent like a franchise player
Deferred compensation is common in professional sports. But your top talent doesn’t need to be a superstar athlete to be paid over time. You typically have two options: a nonqualified deferred compensation plan, or NQDC, and a supplemental executive retirement plan, or SERP. As the employer, a SERP lets you promise executives additional compensation after retirement. In many ways, it can serve a similar function to a vesting schedule for stock options. On the other hand, an NQDC plan uses employee contributions and can allow executives to defer income and potentially reduce current tax liability by spreading earnings over a longer time horizon.
Share reward and risk
Profit sharing is the simplest concept, but for private companies, there’s understandably a great deal of hesitation. In our experience, though, there are ways to use profit sharing that protect ownership, retain your best people, and can even support stronger company performance.
Keys to profit sharing without giving away the books
- Define a transparent profit pool, such as a percentage of EBITDA or gross profit.
- Apply a floor and ceiling to make earnings more predictable.
- Distribute rewards through a deferred-share account that vests over time to mirror a stock option schedule.
Explore after-tax and Roth plan features
Some employers consider adding after-tax contribution and Roth conversion features to their qualified retirement plans as part of their broader benefits strategy. Plan provisions, contribution limits, eligibility, and tax treatment vary, so employers and employees should consult their tax and legal advisors. When appropriately designed, these features may support talent recruitment and retention.
Retain top talent without overpaying or diluting equity
Keeping your best people doesn’t mean handing over equity or stretching payroll to the breaking point. At Marsh Agency, we work in this space every day, designing non-equity incentive packages that align with your business or nonprofit. Let us help you build a retention plan that rewards talented employees, protects your equity, and keeps the organization moving forward.