Scott James
Vice President, MMA Education and Public Entity Practices
While funding challenges vary by region, all school districts are under growing pressure from one budget line: healthcare costs. We’re seeing cost increases driven by several factors, including medical price inflation, higher utilization as employees resume deferred care, and outsized pharmacy spending—especially on specialty medications. Districts should move away from reactive plan changes and toward year-round plan management, stronger governance, and more disciplined vendor management.
The overall rise in costs is affecting the market broadly. Employer health coverage has seen persistent increases, and public-sector plans are not insulated from those forces. According to Mercer’s 2025 National Survey of Employer-Sponsored Health Plans, total health benefit costs increased 6.0% in 2025 to $17,496. In 2026, these costs are expected to increase by 6.7%. This represents the highest increase in the past 15 years.
A survey conducted by The School Superintendents Association (AASA) and Association of School Business Officials International (ASBO International) found that 98% of district leaders said rising healthcare costs were measurably affecting their budgets, with prescription drug costs leading the increase. As a result, many districts are modifying employee benefits packages and delaying hiring or spending on instructional materials and technology.
Another major cost driver is the concentration of risk. A relatively small number of high-cost claims can affect an entire district’s renewal, especially for self-funded plans. Pharmacy is another accelerant, with specialty drugs, GLP-1 medications, and emerging cell and gene therapies putting pressure on plan sponsors that weren’t designed for million-dollar-plus episodes of care.
Education is different from the private sector because of its demographics. Many school districts have a stable, long-tenured workforce and meaningful retiree benefit expectations or liabilities. That can increase chronic condition prevalence and drive consistent utilization while also limiting flexibility in plan design changes. Add local funding constraints and regulatory requirements, and districts can find themselves absorbing cost growth until the only option feels like a disruptive shift.
While quick-fix measures that shift plan costs to employees are often unavoidable, the most effective cost strategies typically focus on improving the total cost of care over the long run, not just shifting costs from the organization to the employee.
One approach gaining traction is aligning care to outcomes through value-based models. When implemented with discipline, value-based care can reduce avoidable complications and improve long-term claims patterns in areas such as diabetes, cardiovascular care, respiratory care, musculoskeletal care, and oncology support.
Primary care access is another concern. When members can’t get timely appointments, they often default to urgent care or the emergency room, and chronic conditions go unmanaged. You can evaluate advanced primary care models, including Direct Primary Care (DPC) in some cases, because reliable primary care access can reduce downstream utilization over time. For larger organizations, on-site or near-site clinics can also help expand access to care.
Figuring out which strategies best align with your district comes down to data. Companies and school districts can reduce costs by leveraging claims and utilization analytics to identify what’s driving spending, then focusing on a few targeted interventions rather than trying to launch every new program or service that comes to market.
Many districts can create meaningful improvement by tightening plan management basics and focusing on pharmacy and high-cost claim governance. The goal is to avoid benefit cuts while ensuring dollars are directed toward high-value care and employees have help navigating the system.
Immediate actions that can produce short-term impact include:
Regardless of the changes, communication with employees and change management are especially important in union environments and public settings. Clear messaging can reduce confusion, increase adoption of high-value programs, and protect trust.
Long-term cost control typically requires districts to invest in access, navigation, and governance. These are the areas that gradually reduce the overall trend and make the plan less vulnerable to disruptive renewal spikes.
School districts often see the best multiyear results by focusing on a few priorities:
Without a stable governance model, districts can cycle between reacting to renewal increases and making abrupt changes that frustrate employees and complicate bargaining. Districts that do this well generally set a clear benefits philosophy, leverage available reporting, and establish a predictable annual decision cadence that includes stakeholders early.
Funding strategy matters as much as plan design. For self-funded districts, effective stop-loss management is important and requires active, professional oversight. Contract terms, lasering policies, renewal rate caps, gene and cell therapy protections, and high-cost claimant strategies can all influence year-to-year volatility.
If your district is not large enough to have credible, predictable claims experience, you can explore scale strategies such as consortiums, cooperative purchasing, or regional partnerships. The goal is to gain leverage in vendor contracting, expand access to clinics or navigation programs, and reduce administrative duplication. Be sure to consider how renewals are determined, the termination language, voting rights, and the market review process so the carriers and vendors continue to represent the most competitive and advantageous option available.
When employee contributions need to change, the most sustainable approach is usually targeted and tied to value so recruitment and retention aren’t undermined. Tiered networks, incentives for high-value providers, and carefully designed contribution strategies can help, but they require strong communication.
If districts want to control school district healthcare costs, they need a small set of shared metrics that are tracked consistently and discussed transparently. The most useful measures should be evaluated on a routine basis, such as quarterly, and typically include:
Districts should look for partners who can provide more than recommendations. Transparent reporting that helps the district measure outcomes from its strategies is important. Piloting innovations can be a smart approach, as long as the pilot is designed with baseline metrics, a clear hypothesis, and a decision point to expand or stop.
School leaders can make meaningful progress by managing their employee benefits program with a strategic approach that is governed, measured, and improved year over year. An important part of that improvement is protecting access, supporting employees, and strengthening the ability to recruit and retain talent.
If your district wants to take a strategic approach to maintaining competitive benefits, you can download How K-12 School Districts Can Build a Smarter Benefits Strategy, which expands benefits strategy beyond cost alone.
Key insights for school districts on employee benefits strategy
Guidance for better planning
Vice President, MMA Education and Public Entity Practices